Eminem at Oslo Sommertid in 2018. Photo by Premeditated via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Eight Mile Style and Martin Affiliated, music publishers whose catalog includes Eminem songs, sued Suno on November 6 in federal court in Northern California. They allege the company copied 269 compositions without permission to train its AI music generator. The filing names songs including “Lose Yourself,” “Stan” and “The Real Slim Shady.” Read the federal complaint
The publishers ask the court for up to $150,000 for each work found to have been willfully infringed. Across all 269 works, that comes to $40.35 million in potential statutory copyright damages. The complaint also requests an injunction and an accounting of the training data at issue. The public docket reviewed for this story showed the case at the filing and assignment stage. Public docket
The complaint points to training and generated tracks
The publishers allege Suno gathered material from online sources and bypassed access controls in the process. They also cite tracks generated through Suno as part of their case. In one example, the complaint puts the opening, first verse and chorus of “Lose Yourself” alongside a Suno track that the publishers say reproduced those passages. Complaint, paragraphs 52 and 98
A Suno spokesperson told Reuters on November 9 that the service helps users make original music and prohibits unauthorized use of artists’ work. Reuters also reported that Elvis Presley’s rightsholders filed a separate case against Suno on the same day. Suno’s response, via Reuters
Why the songwriting rights matter
A composition covers the underlying music and lyrics. A sound recording covers a particular recorded performance. Those copyrights can have different owners, which matters when a music company licenses a catalog or brings a claim over how a song was used. U.S. Copyright Office
Warner Music Group previously announced a licensing partnership with Suno that resolved its own lawsuit. The new case puts a different catalog before a different court. The publishers are asking to see what Suno copied and how it used that material, questions that go to whether the owners of the underlying songs had a say in their use. Warner Music Group’s announcement
